35., 36. & 37. The Cairo Trilogy, by Naguib Mahfouz

31 Dec

Screen Shot 2014-12-30 at 8.47.32 PM

“It had occurred to her once, during the first year she lived with him, to venture a polite objection to his repeated nights out. His response had been to seize her by the ears and tell her peremptorily in a loud voice, ‘I’m a man. I’m the one who commands and forbids. I will not accept any criticism of my behavior. All I ask of you is to obey me. Don’t force me to discipline you.’ She learned from this and from the other lessons that followed to adapt to everything, even living with the jinn, in order to escape the glare of his wrathful eye.”

Thus begins Palace Walk, set in the early part of the last century, the first volume in the Cairo Trilogy by Naguib Mahfouz and the only book originally written in Arabic that’s included in the Everyman’s Library. The woman is Amina, an illiterate daughter of a cleric married at 14 to Al-Sayid Ahmad, a much older respectable merchant who does not allow her, ever, to leave her house (except to visit her mother a few times a year, in his company). He, on the other hand, goes out and drinks every night with his friends, and sleeps with entertainers/loose women. Both Amina and Al-Sayid are portrayed as representatives of the virtues of their society, hers femininity, submission, patience, motherhood, unworldliness, loyalty, obedience and so on. His virtues are authority, success, charm, virility, devotion to his family and a successful navigation between the spheres of public and private.

A description of Amina early-on relates her perfect happiness with the conditions of her life (without this happiness and acceptance she could hardly embody the virtues she does).

“Whenever she thought back over her life, only goodness and happiness came to mind. Fears and sorrows seemed meaningless ghosts to her, worth nothing more than a smile of pity. Had she not lived with this husband and his shortcomings for a quarter century and been rewarded by children who were the apples of her eye, a home amply provided with comforts and blessings, and a happy, adult life? Of course she had. … She even profoundly loved this hour of waiting up…it continued to be a living symbol of her affection for her spouse, of her wholehearted dedication to making him happy….”

For the modern female reader a depiction of life trapped inside one’s house obediently serving a man is difficult to feel comfortable with, but I found Mahfouz’s prose to be so unusual, flowery, elaborate, emotional, smooth and vivid, and the quality of his descriptions of this alien world to be so enthralling that I uneasily went along with it. He uses more exposition than is considered acceptable in today’s fiction-writing, and I felt that the novel had a tranquil, roomy aura because of it.  I was also fairly certain that the idyll being established would be the origin point from which everything unraveled, and in this I was right.

Al-Sayid Ahmad and Amina’s strengths can also be weaknesses. When they are both in their prime they achieve a balance that works, but as their characteristics are passed on to their children unevenly, they become flaws and sources of tragedy. One son is a sensualist and a libertine (one of my favorite characters; see the night he wastedly brings a woman back to his own home and is caught by his wife); a daughter, deprived early of a husband and child, has no further psychological resources; another son is such a sheltered romantic that he becomes a fool.

In the third book and third generation, one grandson becomes a fundamentalist and another a communist, and one (the most successful) is gay, a secretary to a politician and a powerful man in his own right. The repressions and false restrictions of the society don’t seem to do anyone any good, though of course I would think so.

I don’t think Mahfouz is successful at making the Egyptian politics come alive, which is another major component of the books, but he does establish an aura of betrayals and bungling that’s probably something close to the truth, and the early stages of rebellion against British Colonial rule are captivating.


One Response to “35., 36. & 37. The Cairo Trilogy, by Naguib Mahfouz”


  1. Naguib Mahfouz – Beyond the Single Story - April 7, 2019

    […] Courtesy of An Anthology of Clouds […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: